The Archive
Every issue of the Punchbowl News newsletter, including our special editions, right here at your fingertips.
Join the community, and get the morning edition delivered straight to your inbox.
You need voters 50 and over on your side.
Voters 50-plus turn out in greater numbers than any other age group. They’re looking for candidates who will fight for their families and their future. Learn more from our latest polling in North Carolina.
PRESENTED BY
THE TOP
Happy Wednesday morning.
Tuesday’s blockbuster Jan. 6 committee hearing was unprecedented in the array of accusations leveled at a former president and his chief of staff. Not since the days of Richard Nixon and Watergate has the nation been shown a view of a president so seemingly out of control, careening toward a political disaster that still casts a pall over Washington and American politics.
Cassidy Hutchinson, someone who was thought to be a true Donald Trump loyalist, described a series of alarming incidents involving Trump and Mark Meadows, the former White House chief of staff – the two most powerful men in the country – in the days and weeks leading up to the deadly attack on the Capitol. Meadows, Hutchinson’s former boss, was a particularly acute target of Hutchinson and the committee.
Much of the broad arc of what Meadows did during this period has already been disclosed as part of the Senate Judiciary Committee investigation, media reports and books, or even the select committee’s own probe.
Yet what Hutchinson was able to do on Tuesday was fill in some of the holes in that narrative thanks to her own unparalleled access to Meadows and other key West Wing players.
Trump and Meadows, for instance, were aware of the potential for violence for weeks during the lead-up to the congressional certification of Joe Biden’s Electoral College victory on Jan. 6, Hutchinson testified.
After a meeting with Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani in the West Wing on Jan. 2, Meadows cautioned Hutchinson “Things might get real, real bad on Jan. 6,” she testified.
Trump and Meadows were also so inured to the havoc they caused that they dismissed the danger faced by Vice President Mike Pence. Told that some Trump supporters were chanting “hang Mike Pence!” as they marched to the Capitol that day, Meadows informed White House Counsel Pat Cipollone that Trump “doesn’t think they’re doing anything wrong,” Hutchinson said.
So let’s get to some news first, and then we’ll look at some broader takeaways from this historic hearing.
News: At least one of the “witness tampering” messages Rep. Liz Cheney (R-Wyo.) disclosed at the end of the hearing – warnings by unnamed Trump allies to stay loyal to the former president – were sent to Hutchinson, according to a source close to the matter.
Cheney warned that the panel “will be discussing these issues as a committee [and] carefully considering our next steps.” Committee sources didn’t have additional comment late Tuesday.
Takeaways: We wanted to take a moment to discuss some of our observations from Tuesday, as well as the five previous sessions by the select committee.
→ | Trump World fomented the unrest, and then ran away when it got bad. As we noted above, one of the main topics we learned from Hutchinson’s testimony was that senior administration officials were aware of the threat of violence in the period leading up to Jan. 6. They’d been advised repeatedly by law-enforcement and intelligence officials this could happen. These reports reached Meadows personally. |
Meadows and other top White House officials also knew Trump supporters were openly carrying weapons in Washington on Jan. 6, including AR-15 semi-automatic rifles and handguns, according to police reports and witness testimony. Yet Trump himself suggested easing security around the rally on the Ellipse, claiming “They’re not here to hurt me,” Hutchinson testified.
This all plays into the select committee’s position that Trump didn’t seek to tamp down the violence, didn’t take any steps to protect Pence and lawmakers on Capitol Hill, and didn’t call in the National Guard or other military assets to help during the insurrection. Trump, in fact, stood by as the violence grew worse throughout the day.
→ | The wall has cracked. If you asked any Trump world insider who would be the least likely person to testify against the administration, Hutchinson would be atop that list. She was loyal to Trump to a fault – despite what Trump says now. Hutchinson was in every meeting with Meadows and was one of his top defenders. The question is will this spur anymore Trump world insiders to dish? We think probably not. |
→ | What’s DOJ doing on Meadows? The House referred Meadows for criminal contempt of Congress after the former lawmaker refused to comply with the select committees’s subpoena. Earlier this month, the Justice Department said it wouldn’t pursue charges against Meadows for this. But now, following more damning testimony on Meadows’ role in everything leading to the insurrection, will DOJ officials rethink that position? |
→ | An out-of-control president. Throwing plates against the wall. Demanding he be driven to the Capitol during the Jan. 6 insurrection. Not caring about the danger to Pence, his own vice president. Hutchinson painted a picture of Trump as unstable, acting irrationally, completely unable to deal with the fact that he lost the election. It was all an attempt to show that Trump was out of control. And it worked. |
→ | The case for conspiracy got stronger. The select committee made progress in its efforts to prove that Trump’s inner circle knew about the potential for violence at the Capitol and did nothing. To the select committee, the violence was the point. This includes during the insurrection itself, when lawmakers were calling and texting Meadows begging for help. Hutchinson testified that she heard Giuliani discuss the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers – two groups linked to violence – before the attack. If the panel can draw a line between Trump allies and those who planned the attack, that’s extraordinarily damaging. Remember: Giuliani and Meadows sought pardons, Hutchinson testified. |
→ | Pat Cipollone was one bright spot. There weren’t a lot of heroes in the Trump West Wing, but former White House Counsel Pat Cipollone – as well as lawyers Eric Herschmann and Patrick Philbin – has come off relatively well during these hearings. |
Cipollone and the others threatened to resign if Trump appointed Jeffrey Clark as acting attorney general. Cipollone wanted to tone down Trump’s Ellipse speech on Jan. 6. Cipollone warned of possible criminal charges if Trump went to the Capitol that day. Cipollone and the others called on Trump to issue a statement during the attack on the Capitol, although Herschmann is disputing some of Hutchinson’s testimony on what exactly occurred. Philbin and other White House lawyers objected to Trump mentioning pardons in any national speech the day after the insurrection. Cheney has praised Cipollone and Philbin, urging them to cooperate fully with the probe, which they have declined to do. Herschmann, of course, has become a star for his colorful testimony and appearance.
The question we got from nearly everyone last night was does Hutchinson’s testimony change anything. And the answer is probably not. Republicans are locked in. As are Democrats. But we got a number of text messages from Republicans saying that this hearing was particularly searing.
Also: Speaker Nancy Pelosi received communion at a mass attended by Pope Francis at St. Peter’s Basilica at the Vatican. Pelosi met with the pope before the mass and received a blessing.
– Jake Sherman and John Bresnahan
PRESENTED BY META
Doctors can practice high-risk situations risk-free in the metaverse
Body: In the metaverse, future surgeons will be able to practice advanced procedures hundreds of times before seeing real patients – helping them gain experience and master their skills.
The metaverse may be virtual, but the impact will be real.
PUNCHBOWL NEWS EVENTS
What Sununu told us
We were joined by New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu Tuesday for a conversation on small businesses coming out of the pandemic. Sununu, who is seen as a potential GOP presidential candidate in 2024, made a lot of news yesterday. We were also joined by New Hampshire-based small business owners Toutou Marsden and Tim Pipp afterwards in a fireside chat.
ACA SUBSIDIES
Dem govs warn of catastrophe if ACA subsidies expire
More than a dozen Democratic governors wrote to congressional leaders this week, pleading with them to take action to extend the enhanced Obamacare subsidies that will expire at the end of this year – and warning of a disastrous fallout if Congress doesn’t.
If the subsidies aren’t extended, millions of Americans will be forced to pay dramatically increased health care premiums or risk losing their insurance altogether. And the notices announcing the significant cost increase will land in mailboxes in October, just weeks before the midterms.
Read the full letter here. And here’s a key excerpt:
“As inflation continues to put a strain on consumers’ budgets, we are concerned that many people will choose to reduce health insurance coverage or even go without coverage if Congress fails to act. The Biden Administration estimates that approximately 3.4 million consumers currently enrolled could lose coverage if the ARP subsidy expansions expire at the end of 2022.
The expiration of the enhanced subsidies would also lead to a decrease in enrollment and an increase in premiums, destabilizing health insurance markets, and impacting affordability for the broader population.
Additionally, as the Public Health Emergency is expected to end in the coming months, some consumers will no longer be eligible for Medicaid but may become eligible for ACA subsidies. Without the enhanced subsidies to ensure there are affordable marketplace options, those consumers are likely to become uninsured.”
This issue is front of mind for many Democrats, as we’ve written previously. So much so that Speaker Nancy Pelosi raised it in a recent meeting with President Joe Biden and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer.
Pelosi and other House Democratic leaders want to see the premiums extended in a party-line reconciliation bill being negotiated between Schumer and Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.). But Manchin told us Friday that he hasn’t even had discussions on addressing the subsidies in a reconciliation bill, sounding pretty skeptical that would happen.
“I understand the conditions that we have and the challenges people have and everything. That’s something that, you know, in a perfect world, you want to do everything you can do,” Manchin said. “But the bottom line is, we’re strained right now. It’s a big strain.”
– Heather Caygle
PUNCHBOWL NEWS IN NEW YORK!
We hosted a happy hour in New York City last night for partners and friends of Punchbowl News. It was wonderful connecting with our community and taking in a gorgeous view of the Empire State Building from the Spyglass Rooftop Bar in Midtown. Thanks to all who joined!
Raising a glass: Christine Anderson, Alex Katz, Matt Bucci, and Kelli Kahn of Blackstone, Glen Caplin of MLB, Kara Carscaden of Estée Lauder Companies, Scott Mulhauser of Bully Pulpit Interactive, Leigh Farris of Carlyle, Tony Fratto of Hamilton Place Strategies, Risa Heller of Risa Heller Communications, Joanna Rose and Catherine Johnson of Apollo, Jennifer Morris of Anheuser-Busch, Stephan Miller of Kivvit, Sarah Murphy and Zach Bishop of IBM, and Dana Yeganian of Global Strategy Group.
PRESENTED BY META
PRIMARY RECAP
Key takeaways from Tuesday’s primaries
The packed slate of primaries Tuesday made lots of news. Here are some results and our key takeaways.
It’s still former President Donald Trump’s Republican Party.
Trump went in hard to back freshman Freedom Caucus Rep. Mary Miller (R-Ill.) in her primary against Rep. Rodney Davis (R-Ill.). And despite Miller’s controversial comments at a Trump rally on the eve of the 15th District primary — Miller claimed she misspoke when she called Roe’s reversal a “victory for white life” — the first-term lawmakers unseated the more senior Davis.
It’s a humbling defeat for Davis, the top Republican on the House Administration Committee and a close ally of House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy. Davis is far from a moderate but has a reputation for dealmaking. He also supported a bipartisan commission to investigate the Jan. 6 insurrection.
Illinois progressives suffer setbacks in tough night.
In three key House primaries, progressive Democrats had the opportunity to knock off more moderate candidates. But high-profile progressives such as Rep. Marie Newman (D-Ill.) and Justice Democrats-backed Kina Collins lost last night.
Newman was crushed by Rep. Sean Casten (D-Ill.) in the member-on-member primary in the 6th District. While the candidates shared largely similar policy positions, Newman diverted from Casten on her stance toward Israel. A critic of Israel, Newman notably voted against U.S. funding for Israel’s Iron Dome missile defense system in 2021. As a result, Democratic Majority for Israel PAC spent hundreds of thousands of dollars in ads to support Casten. Newman also faced an ethics scandal surrounding her treatment of a former primary rival.
In Illinois’ 7th District, longtime incumbent Rep. Danny Davis (D-Ill.) narrowly defeated Collins, an anti-gun violence activist who drew national attention to the race. Davis’ win was far closer than the first matchup between the candidates in 2020.
One bright spot for progressives, however, appeared in the primary for Illinois’ 3rd District where progressive state Rep. Delia Ramirez beat Chicago Alderman Gilbert Villegas. Ramirez was backed by major national progressives such as Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), in addition to the Congressional Progressive Caucus PAC. Ramirez and her allies attacked Villegas as a lobbyist in multiple TV ads.
Another Jackson is likely headed to Capitol Hill.
Jonathan Jackson, son of civil rights icon Rev. Jesse Jackson Sr., won the Democratic nomination in the crowded primary to replace the retiring Rep. Bobby Rush in Illinois’ 1st District. Jackson is the brother of former Rep. Jesse Jackson, Jr., (D-Ill.), who went to prison for spending hundreds of thousands of dollars in campaign funds on personal expenses. The 1st District has been represented by a Black lawmaker for nearly a century and is overwhelmingly Democratic.
Rep. Markwayne Mullin (R-Okla.) failed to avoid a runoff in the race to become Oklahoma’s newest senator.
Mullin advanced to a Aug. 23 primary runoff against former state House Speaker T.W. Shannon. The race to succeed retiring Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.) attracted a host of candidates, including former EPA administrator Scott Pruitt and Inhofe’s former chief of staff Luke Holland. Mullin ran far ahead of the pack, but ended up a couple of percentage points short of clearing 50%.
It was a mixed night for Republican incumbents in Mississippi.
Incumbent GOP Rep. Michael Guest survived a challenge, while Rep. Steven Palazzo was unseated in two closely watched primary runoffs.
Guest beat retired Navy pilot Michael Cassidy in the 3rd District primary runoff. Cassidy had attacked Guest for voting to establish a bipartisan commission to investigate the Jan. 6 insurrection. A burst of funding from the House GOP leadership-aligned Congressional Leadership Fund PAC ripped Cassidy as a closet socialist.
Sheriff Mike Ezell knocked off Palazzo in the 4th District primary runoff. The incumbent faced question marks over a 2021 ethics investigation that found “substantial evidence” that Palazzo misspent campaign funds. Palazzo was a part of the gigantic GOP class of 2010.
Colorado Republicans achieved the first step in their long-shot bid to knock off Sen. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.).
A relatively moderate businessman Joe O’Dea, who has expressed support for abortion rights, triumped over right-wing state Rep. Ron Hanks in the Colorado Senate GOP primary. Democratic PACs had spent millions of dollars in the GOP primary in an effort to elevate Hanks, who was perceived as an easier candidate for Bennet to face in November.
While Colorado is turning into a reliably blue state, some Republicans believe O’Dea is the right candidate to seize on voter dissatisfaction with the economy and pull off an upset.
Rep. Tom Suozzi’s gubernatorial gamble didn’t pay off.
New York Democrats were peeved when Suozzi ditched a competitive Long Island seat to mount a gubernatorial challenge against Gov. Kathy Hochul. Months later, all Suozzi has to show for his troubles is a third-place, sub-15% showing. The moderate Democrat tried to portray Hochul as soft on crime; it didn’t stick with voters.
Rep. Lee Zeldin (R-N.Y.) advanced from the Republican primary to face off against Hochul in November. This will be in an uphill battle in blue New York, but Zeldin was able to defeat fellow Republican Andrew Giuliani in a hard-fought win to get this far.
— Max Cohen and John Bresnahan
THE CAMPAIGN
→ | New: A recent Cygnal poll commissioned by the Republican State Leadership Committee over the weekend found that just 8% of likely voters in national battleground states say abortion is the most important issue in their voting calculus. Warning: this is a party poll, but it’s what the RSLC is sending out to its candidates, so we wanted to bring you inside their thinking. |
In a new memo, RSLC leadership argues the impact of striking down Roe on the 2022 election is overblown. Most voters cite the economy and inflation as their top priority, the memo states — issue areas where Republicans claim to hold an advantage over Democrats. Check out the full memo here.
The memo is a good look at how Republicans are reacting to the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision. The RSLC is adamant that voters are still laser-focused on the economy; 37% of respondents said inflation/high cost of living was their top issue and 16% chose the economy in general.
The poll also found that 30% of likely voters said a candidate’s position on abortion is the “absolute most important issue to them.” 65% of respondents said other issues would determine who they would vote for in November. Another notable data point: just 21% of independents surveyed said abortion is “the absolute most important issue to them.”
Some more interesting nuggets from the poll:
Only 23% of likely voters think the country is on the right track compared to 74% who say it’s on the wrong track.
→ | [President Joe] Biden is underwater at 41% favorable, 57% unfavorable. |
Republicans state legislative candidates still lead on the generic ballot (47%-45%).
Details on the methodology: 2,007 likely general election voters in Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Michigan, Minnesota, Maine, Nevada, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin were polled via an online panel from June 25 to 26. The survey has a margin of error of +/- 2.19%.
— Max Cohen
FRONTS
PRESENTED BY META
MOMENTS
All times eastern
President Joe Biden is at the NATO summit in Madrid. He is attending the first session with other heads of state.
8:25 a.m.: Biden will attend a trilateral meeting with South Korean President Yoon Suk-Yeol and Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida.
9 a.m.: Biden will attend the second NATO session.
11:45 a.m.: Biden will meet with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.
1:05 p.m.: Biden will attend the Transatlantic Dinner at the Prado Museum.
2:45 p.m.: Vice President Kamala Harris will fly to San Francisco from D.C.
CLIP FILE
NYT
→ | “Trump Aides Watch Testimony and Brace for Damage,” by Mike Bender and Maggie Haberman |
→ | “Cassidy Hutchinson’s Testimony Highlights Legal Risks for Trump,” by Alan Feuer and Glenn Thrush |
→ | “NATO will sharply increase the number of troops it keeps on standby,” by Steven Erlanger |
→ | “In Blow to Putin, Turkey Won’t Bar Sweden and Finland From NATO,” by Steven Erlanger in Madrid, Valerie Hopkins in Kremenchuk, Ukraine, Anton Troianovski in Paris and Michael D. Shear in Madrid |
WaPo
→ | “Cassidy Hutchinson’s path from trusted insider to explosive witness,” by Michael Kranish, Josh Dawsey, Jacqueline Alemany and Eugene Scott |
→ | Dan Balz: “Trump’s had bad moments, but few worse than Cassidy Hutchinson’s testimony” |
WSJ
→ | “FTC Accuses Walmart of Letting Scammers Use Its Money-Transfer Services,” by Sarah Nassauer |
→ | “U.S., Iran Gather for Indirect Talks on Nuclear-Deal Revival,” by Laurence Norman and Benoit Faucon |
Bloomberg
→ | “‘They Do Not Want Us,’ Ukraine Says of NATO as Leaders Meet,” by Marc Champion and Daryna Krasnolutska |
Politico
→ | “Eastman drops bid to block phone records from Jan. 6 committee,” by Kyle Cheney |
→ | “Ginni Thomas lawyer has ‘serious concerns’ about Jan. 6 committee fairness,” by Betsy Woodruff Swan and Nick Wu |
→ | “Abortion doctors’ post-Roe dilemma: Move, stay or straddle state lines,” by Alice Miranda Ollstein |
USA Today
→ | “Abortion is no longer a constitutional right. Americans are afraid Plan B is next,” by Bailey Schulz |
LA Times
→ | “Data breach exposes private info of all California concealed-carry permit holders,” by Gregory Yee |
PRESENTED BY META
The metaverse may be virtual, but the impact will be real
Body: Meta is helping build the metaverse so aviation mechanics will be able to practice servicing different jet engines – preparing them for any complex job.
The result: A more skilled workforce.
Editorial photos provided by Getty Images
Crucial Capitol Hill news AM, Midday, and PM—5 times a week
Join a community of some of the most powerful people in Washington and beyond. Exclusive newsmaker events, parties, in-person and virtual briefings and more.
Subscribe to PremiumThe Canvass Year-End Report
And what senior aides and downtown figures believe will happen in 2023.
Check it outEvery single issue of Punchbowl News published, all in one place
Visit the archiveAARP knows older voters.
We’ve made it our business to know what matters to people 50 and over—like we know that protecting Social Security and supporting family caregivers are among their top priorities. Learn more from our polling in North Carolina.